Friday, April 19, 2024

Female v. Male Paintings in 19th Century France

     Men and women worked as artists in nineteenth-century France, but they were not treated equally as artists during this time period. Women were barred from opportunities to study as the men studied, especially the inability to study the nude body, whether male or female. Female artists were also not getting as many big commissions as other male artists were which made their hunt for success even more difficult. In this exhibition, we are going to explore the differences between male and female artists in nineteenth-century France. This exhibition explores the different experiences of male and female artists in nineteenth-century France, paying attention to subject matter and process. Emerging female artists were unable to learn artistic skills like their male counterparts, they had to create their own art while being excluded from schools of art. They turned to animals and landscapes or even painted their lady friends in the confines of their own homes. Men got to study the nude body and implement the bodies in their pieces or even have the honor of traveling to homes to paint. This exhibition highlights the differences that male and female artists faced as they produced paintings as commissions or simply just for their own desires. 




Rosa Bonheur, The Horse Fair, 1852-55. Oil on canvas, 96 1/4 in. x 199 1/2 in. (244.5 cm x 506.7 cm), Gift of Cornelius Vanderbilt, 1887, Accession Number: 87.25

    The first painting in this exhibition is The Horse Fair curated by French female artist Rosa Bonheur. This painting is a composition of carefully created horses as they ride along the plain of the canvas adding texture and movement to the piece from their different heights and lengths. Bonheur chose to keep animals as her major subject of her compositions because she did not have a ton of skill or desire to paint accurate humans; nor did she have the opportunity to learn how to paint the human body in its rawest form. She would go to slaughterhouses and other places to obtain knowledge of animal anatomy. Female artists had to push themselves even further to be seen as equal to their male counterparts. Bonheur does this by being extremely skillful in painting animals.


Rosa Bonheur, Weaning the Calves, 1879. Oil on canvas, 25 5/8 x 32 in. (65.1 x 81.3), Catharine Lorillard Wolfe Collection, Bequest of Catharine Lorillard Wolfe, 1887, Accession Number: 87.15.109


    Another piece by Rosa Bonheur is Weaning the Calves. This piece also highlights her choice of animals instead of people. Bonheur believes that her decision to paint animals was because, in her eyes, they are innocent creatures with desires to break free of human bonds. Bonheur feels the same way. As a female artist in the nineteenth century, it is difficult to be equal with male artists. Since painting nude is seen as higher art, females supposedly would never reach that point, so they had to become excellent with the abilities they had without going to school for art. They had to supposedly be better than male artists to be recognized as equal to them.



Berthe Morisot, Young Woman Seated on a Sofa, 1879. Oil on canvas, 31 3/4 x 39 1/4 in. (80.6 x 99.7 cm), Partial and Promised Gift of Mr. and Mrs. Douglas Dillon, 1992, Accession Number: 1992.103.2
    Another female artist who was successful in nineteenth-century France was Berthe Morisot. Her subject matter was impressionist portraits of females who are enjoying domestic life. Morisot painted domestic life, which is where she was restricted to. Her use of color and lights creates the composition to be calm and delicate. Her work was seen as very feminine. Traveling to public places to paint for women in the nineteenth century was frowned upon, so she had to truly enhance her skill of painting women in the domestic setting. Like private gardens where Morisot could easily set up her paint supplies and paint one of her friends. Morisot does her best to accurately portray the women that she paints but some things are off, like the subject may look flat, or even body parts simply appear from the dresses.



Berthe Morisot, The Pink Dress (Albertie-Marguerite CarrĂ©, later Madame Ferdinand-Henri Himmes, 1854–1935), 1870. Oil on canvas, 21 1/2 x 26 1/2 in. (54.6 x 67.3 cm), The Walter H. and Leonore Annenberg Collection, Bequest of Walter H. Annenberg, 2002, Accession Number: 2003.20.8

    A second art piece by Berthe Morisot is The Pink Dress. This is one of her early works where she did a portrait of Madame Ferdinand-Henri Himmes. Like the previously shown painting, Young Woman Seated on a Sofa, this piece also highlights the restrictions that female artists had to abide by. It is a painting of domestic life that is indoors instead of out in a garden. Along with different subject matter(animals), female artists also had to pave their own path by being stuck in private homes instead of public places. Female artists were still able to paint human subjects, but they were always clothed. It appears that they had more knowledge of painting what the women were wearing rather than considering what the woman looked like underneath her garments.


Edouard Manet, Fishing, ca. 1862-63. Oil on canvas, 30 1/4 x 48 1/2 in. (76.8 x 123.2 cm), Purchase, Mr. and Mrs. Richard J. Bernhard Gift, 1957, Accession Number: 57.10

    After looking at female artists of nineteenth-century France, we have more insight into the greater opportunities that male artists had during this time. Edouard Manet is featured in this exhibition because he is a successful male artist but also because he chooses compositions of people in more public places. This painting in particular, Fishing, shows that men went out to public places to paint their subjects. Manet chooses to do a lot of landscape paintings while still incorporating his knowledge of the human body in his pieces. This piece is also a portrait of a soon-to-be-wed couple, the male and female in the bottom right corner. This painting shows that male artists had the greater ability to go out and paint and also get commissioned by well-known people to paint them.



Edouard Manet, The Monet Family in Their Garden at Argenteuil, 1874. Oil on canvas, 24 x 39 1/4 in. (61 x 99.7 cm), Bequest of Joan Whitney Payson, 1975, Accession Number: 1976.201.14
    Another piece by Manet is The Monet Family in Their Garden at Argenteuil. This piece accentuates the opportunities that male artists have. Female artists can get commissions, but it isn't that high of a percentage because they are restricted to being stuck in domestic life, there is a lesser chance that they could go out to more public places, or even other private settings to paint commission work; they had to follow the rules of women in society. This piece of the Monet family proves that male artists have more opportunities to do such a thing. Since Manet had the ability to study the nude figure, he can add form and shape to the family members in this composition, unlike the flatness that female artists unintentionally make their human subjects appear to be.



Gustave Courbet, The Young Bather, 1866. Oil on canvas, 51 1/4 x 38 1/4 in. (130.2 x 97.2 cm),  H. O. Havemeyer Collection, Bequest of Mrs. H. O. Havemeyer, 1929, Accession Number: 29.100.124

    A second male artist that is featured is Gustave Courbet. This male artist pays special attention to the nude female body. This pair of paintings is a subject matter that you may never see in female paintings. Females could easily paint nude children because mothers are always around those little nude bodies, but you will not see females paint nude women in more sensual poses in the public atmosphere. They needed to stay innocent. Courbet paints the entirety of the female nude, he paints every roll and crevice of the nude body. He emphasizes her by playing with the concept of space and scale. Male artists went to school where they were able to be in the same room as a woman who is nude so this woman in the painting is accurately painted because of the studying that Courbet was able to do.



Gustave Courbet, Woman with a Parrot, 1866. Oil on canvas, 51 x 77 in. (129.5 x 195.6 cm), H. O. Havemeyer Collection, Bequest of Mrs. H. O. Havemeyer, 1929, Accession Number: 29.100.57
    The last piece in this curation is also a Courbet painting named Woman with a Parrot. In addition to the last painting, this is also a subject of the nude. Courbet paints a woman who is posed in a lying down position much like Manet’s Olympia. This pose is filled with sensual emotions. The body is emphasized by the contrast between the dark background and the pale skin of the woman. Male artists, Courbet in particular, choose to have the subjects of their paintings be the majority female nude. This could be because they had the opportunity to study those particular bodies, or even because it makes them stand out as male artists. This painting is more masculine because of the pose of the woman and also the stark contrast between colors. Male artists were not denied the opportunity to study nude bodies, unlike female artists.


References:

Myers, Nicole. “Women Artists in Nineteenth-Century France: Essay: The Metropolitan Museum of Art: Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History.” The Met’s Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, September 2008. https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/19wa/hd_19wa.htm. 


Vaughan William. 1994.
Romanticism and Art. London: Thames and Hudson.

Japonisme, the Beautiful Mundane: The Influence of Japanese Art upon Impressionism

 In the mid 1850s, Japan opened its doors. Isolationism ended. Once more the country began to trade, entering again into global culture. And so, suddenly a great wave of Japanese art flooded into Europe and especially into France. Japanese articles such as silks, fans, kimonos, ceramics, and parasols began to circulate. Eventually, woodcut prints within a school of art called ukiyo-e became more and more common and began to interest Impressionist artists. Figures such as Claude Monet, Edgar Degas, Mary Cassatt, and Edouard Manet admired and studied these prints along with other Japanese objects and subsequently began to imitate and reference them in their own work. A new movement emerged: Japonisme, European art that demonstrated heavy Japanese influence.

Japanese objects began to appear within Impressionistic paintings and artists attempted to imitate Japanese techniques. Most interestingly, key stylistic features of ukiyo-e emerged within Impressionistic painting. Many Japanese prints utilized asymmetry, aerial perspective, bright color, and prominent contour lines. Impressionist artists began to incorporate these features into their own work, breaking from traditional European perspective and technique. Moreover, Japanese art in the mid 1850s focused upon portraying the ordinary, the mundane. French artists observed this practice and attached themselves to it. Impressionism had already begun to depart from traditional European subject matter. The influence of Japan only expedited the process. No longer did artists content themselves with history painting or commissions. Instead, they painted scenes of everyday life. Ultimately, the influx of Japanese art into France spurred artists to shy away from portraying scenes of grandiose nature and to instead capture glimpses of everyday life in unique perspectives. 


Camille Pissaro, Jeanne Holding A Fan, c. 1873, oil on canvas, The Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford

    


    This piece portrays a little girl in a blue frock sitting, hunched, in a chair while holding a paper fan. She is positioned just off center, looking directly out at the viewer, her fan drooping dejectedly. At first, we might question how a work such as this could be influenced by Japanese art. Then we recognize Jeanne's fan. Pissaro includes a portrayal of actual Japanese subject matter. Without Japan's decision to end its isolationism, there would be no way for a little French girl to possess such an object.


James McNeill Whistler, La Princesse Du Pays de la Porcelaine, 1864, oil on canvas, Freer Gallery of Art, Washington, DC


This artwork features a tall woman wearing a kimono, holding another Japanese fan, standing in front of a Japanese screen. It is even more Japanese in its subject matter than Jeanne Holding a Fan. In this painting we see not only the heightened presence of Japanese objects in Europe, but also the French fascination with them. The woman pictured stands in a room literally filled with Japanese art. Through her we see France's captivation with the flowing fabric, the fashion, and the flowery and patterned instruments of the Japanese. 


Mary Cassatt, Maternal Caress, 1890-91, drypoint, aquatint and soft ground etching; printed in color from three plates; sixth state of six, Accession number: 16.2.5


 Not only did Impressionist artists depict objects from Japan, they also experimented with Japanese methods. In this work, Cassatt imitates the actual process of ukiyo-e woodblock printing, using a method called aquatint. Maternal Caress features flat planes of color and defined contour lines, making it very formally similar to many ukiyo-e prints. Additionally, we begin to see the artist's focus shift to the mundane. This mother and her child are not famous historically or popularly. They are ordinary people engaged in ordinary tasks. 


Vincent van Gogh, La Berceuse (Woman Rocking a Cradle; Augustine-Alix Pellicot Roulin, 1851–1930), 1889, oil on canvas, Accession Number: 1996.435


   La Berceuse also pictures an ordinary woman, a mundane figure rather than an incredible one. In this work, we see more traditional European technique overlap with Japanese technique. This is not a print, but oil on canvas, so it was not made in the same way a Japanese ukiyo-e would have been. However, it still uses heavy line, flat expanses of color, patterns, and aerial perspective as the prints would. Instead of light and dark creating depth, line gives us a sense of form. Instead of delicate layers of color, flat expanses of solid green, teal and red greet our eyes. 


Claude Monet, Garden at Sainte-Adresse, 1867, oil on canvas, Accession Number: 67.241

Monet's painting portrays a lovely terrace on the edge of the ocean. Several fashionable figures enjoy the sunny day while colorful flowers bloom brightly around them and two crisp flags wave above. Japanese influence might not seem as obvious in this painting. There are no crisp contour lines or distinctly Japanese subjects. However, color is blocked in a way that reminisces woodblock printing and the perspective is distinctly Japanese. In fact, Monet's painting seems to directly reference one specific print: Katsushika Hokusai's  The Sazoido of Gohyaku Rakan-Ji Temple. Both images show a terrace with figures gazing out over a body of water. The perspective of the viewer is almost the same in both: slightly from above and looking down into the scene. And once more, this is not a history painting or a portrayal of famous persons. Rather, it is an ordinary moment. 


Edouard Manet, Boating, oil on canvas, 1874, Accession Number: 29.100.115


Boating, similar to Garden at Sainte-Adresse, might be at first tricky to recognize as Japonisme. However, it too features wide blocks of color. In fact, Manet only really uses three hues in Boating -white, blue, and brown- and arranges them sectionally. Again, we do not recognize these people. They are simply two ordinary figures enjoying a boat ride. Even more significantly, this work demonstrates cropping. Japanese prints were distinctive in their unusual perspective and cropping of the picture plane. In the same way, Boating has no horizon line. The water extends up and up behind the boat.

Edgar Degas,
Racecourse, Amateur Jockeys,
c. 1876-87, oil on canvas, Musée d'Orsay



This final work also utilizes a cropped perspective. The viewer seems to be standing behind a vehicle, the back wheels of a carriage obscuring the bottom right corner of the piece. Furthermore, Degas's painting also references a specific Japanese print: Utagawa Hiroshige's The Ushimachi Quarter in Takanawa from "One Hundred Views of Famous Places in Edo." But Degas's work, while from a Japanese work, is even less an imitation of it than Manet's Boating or Monet's Garden. For instance, there are even fewer contour lines and the use of colour is more nuanced. Instead, it is an example of the attitude at which Impressionists eventually arrived in their exploration of Japanese art. Japonisme did not copy Japanese prints. It used loose brushwork and oil paint, not woodblock printing. Instead, it ultimately borrowed specific stylistic elements of woodblock art in order to more interestingly convey impressions of the beautiful, mundane world.



Chains of Fate

 Unveiling the Chains of Fate: Understanding the Purpose Behind Biblical Narratives.      The concept of "Chains of Fate" asserts that the events depicted in the Bible narratives are interconnected by a divine plan, where each story unfolds with purpose, contributing to the overarching narrative of salvation and divine intervention. The Bible presents a series of narratives spanning across generations and cultures, yet they are intricately linked by themes of redemption, covenant, and providence. Each event, character, and circumstance plays a crucial role in shaping the overarching storyline, emphasizing the interconnectedness of divine providence and human history.

Title: Saint Francis

Artist: Federico Barocci (Italian, Urbino ca. 1535–1612 Urbino)

Date: ca. 1600–1604

Medium: Oil on canvas

Dimensions: 35 3/8 x 30 7/8 in. (89.9 x 78.4 cm); with added strips 35 7/8 x 31 3/8 in. (91.1 x 79.7 cm)

Classification: Paintings


“Barocci’s naturalism, heightened emotion, and coloristic brilliance helped set the stage for what became known as Baroque art. His subtle, soft surface textures were inspired in part by the Italian Mannerist painter Correggio” (The Met). While Saint Francis is not mentioned in the Bible, he is known for the Franciscan Order which emphasizes simplicity and service to the lowly. The significance of the nails in his hands likely correspond with the wounds of Jesus Christ which is also displayed in the picture. The wounds on Saint Francis’ hands reflect the wounds on Jesus’ hands as well.

Title: The Denial of Saint Peter

Artist: Caravaggio (Michelangelo Merisi) (Italian, Milan or Caravaggio 1571–1610 Porto Ercole)

Date: 1610

Medium: Oil on canvas

Dimensions: 37 x 49 3/8 in. (94 x 125.4 cm)

Classification: Paintings



When Jesus was caught by the Jewish leaders, Peter, one of his closest friends, followed from a distance. He ended up in the courtyard of the high priest's house, where Jesus was questioned. Later, two people accused Peter of being with Jesus. Peter said he didn't know Jesus. Then, a rooster crowed, just like Jesus had said it would, reminding Peter of what Jesus had warned. Peter felt really bad about denying Jesus. This moment made Peter realize how wrong he had been. It changed his life. Later, Peter felt sorry for what he did, and Jesus forgave him. The story of the Denial of Saint Peter serves as a tale about the frailty of human loyalty and the consequences of succumbing to fear and weakness. The theme of forgiveness and redemption, as Peter's denial ultimately becomes a catalyst for his spiritual growth and transformation.


Title: Samson Captured by the Philistines
Artist: Guercino (Giovanni Francesco Barbieri) (Italian, Cento 1591–1666 Bologna)

Date: 1619

Medium: Oil on canvas

Dimensions: 75 1/4 x 93 1/4 in. (191.1 x 236.9 cm)

Classification: Paintings
Samson fought against the Philistines, Israel's enemies. He struggled with moral weaknesses, particularly concerning women, and fell in love with Delilah, who betrayed him by cutting his hair, the source of his strength. The central idea of Samson’s story depicts one of triumph and tragedy, showcasing the consequences of pride, lust, and disobedience, as well as the redemptive power of God's mercy and forgiveness.

Title: The Lamentation

Artist: Ludovico Carracci (Italian, Bologna 1555–1619 Bologna)

Date: ca. 1582

Medium: Oil on canvas

Dimensions: 37 1/2 x 68 in. (95.3 x 172.7 cm)

Classification: Paintings

The idea behind “The Lamentation” is supposed to make viewers feel a sense of remorse for Jesus Christ laying dead on the white cloth. The position of Mary’s head “thrown back in an experimental pose” is supposed to result in a “stylized frieze of mourners” (The Met). When taking a closer look at the painting, we are able to connect with the women in the painting who are in distress about having to wrap Jesus in this cloth. The theme of redemption is coming soon, but first, viewers need to connect with this painting and feel the pain that Jesus had to endure. Jesus enduring death is the pivotal point in Christianity that changed the life of Christians forever.


Title: Hagar and the Angel

Artist: Francesco Maffei (Italian, Vicenza 1605–1660 Padua)

Date: ca. 1657

Medium: Oil on canvas

Dimensions: 41 3/4 x 54 in. (106 x 137.2 cm)

Classification: Paintings

Hagar, Sarah's servant, became pregnant with Abraham's child. When mistreated by Sarah, Hagar fled into the desert, where an angel found her. The angel instructed her to return and promised her son, Ishmael, would become a great nation. After Isaac's birth, tensions rose again, and Hagar and Ishmael were sent away. In the wilderness, when they ran out of water, God intervened, providing for them and promising Ishmael's future (The Met). The theme in this painting is how Hagar needed Divine guidance, the Angel, to point her back
to a promised life of goodness.

Title: The Burial of Christ

Artist: Annibale Carracci (Italian, Bologna 1560–1609 Rome)

Date: 1595

Medium: Oil on copper

Dimensions: 17 1/4 x 13 3/4 in. (43.8 x 34.9 cm)

Classification: Paintings


 Inside of this dark cave, we see a group of people who are about to bury Christ. This painting is to signify the importance of what is to come soon. The “Light on the horizon signals either sunset on his earthly life or sunrise in anticipation of a new beginning with his resurrection” (The Met). A new day is coming, but it's not what people think. The theme represented in this painting is the promise from the beginning of time, that God would save all of humanity.